Public Watchdog.org

The Watchdog’s Kibbles And Bits – Box 4

02.01.08

Corporate Welfare, Park Ridge Style:  As reported on this site and in both local newspapers this week, the City is giving Napleton Cadillac $400,000 of our money to grease Napleton’s sale of its old Cadillac dealership location to Uptown developer PRC LLP, for construction of more multi-family housing. 

The purchase price of that property?  Bill Napleton refused to answer that question posed by First Ward Ald. Dave Schmidt, as well as Schmidt’s question about what Napleton paid for the property.  Napleton also wouldn’t, or couldn’t, come up with a good answer to 7th Ward Ald. Frank Wsol’s question about why this could be considered a good deal for Park Ridge.  Napleton did admit, however, that the property was appraised at between $4 Million and $5 Million, so it would appear that this is yet another case (see, e.g., Executive Office Plaza) of greed over need.

But that’s not all.  Over the next 15 years, Napleton gets to keep up to $2 Million of what would otherwise be the City’s sales tax revenue.  In return, Napleton will remodel its new location and stay in Park Ridge for those 15 years.  So effectively we’re giving – not lending, but outright giving – Napleton the money to remodel its new dealership. 

The architect of this windfall to Napleton?  It sure looks like Mayor Howard Frimark, whose mayoral campaign fund received a $1,000 contribution from Napleton.  Frimark apparently assumed the role of the City’s lead negotiator with Napleton and then got to cast the tie-breaking vote to approve the deal.  Now that’s convenient.

Meanwhile, Back At The Budget Ranch:  While our City Council was busy giving Napleton its sweetheart deal, it was also busy figuring out ways to gouge us ordinary citizens with more taxes to fill the $600,000 budget hole for 2008.  Get ready for yet another 5% increase in the City’s share of our property taxes, an increase in the taxes when you buy/sell real estate, a 5-10% increase in water rates, or a combination of these. 

But just think how good you’ll feel when you go to purchase a new Cadillac in the remodeled Napleton dealership you helped pay for.

But There’s Always Money For More Land:  As reported by Craig Adams in this week’s Park Ridge Journal (“Alderman Upset Over Treatment Of Taxpayer $$$,” Jan. 30), the City Council agreed – in another “closed session” – to offer American Eagle Insurance $1.1 Million for its property at 720 Garden Street, presumably as the site for the proposed new police station.  Amazingly, the City’s offer was $200,000 more than the City’s own appraisal [pdf], which led First Ward Ald. Dave Schmidt to complain that the Council is “treating the taxpayer money like Monopoly money.” 

This isn’t the first time, Alderman.

Ald. Schmidt v. The “Culture of Secrecy”:  And speaking of Ald. Schmidt, he once again proved to be The People’s champion not only by protesting the closed sessions that seem to be used more and more by the Frimark Administration to foster its Culture of Secrecy, but also by releasing to the press certain memos from lame-duck City Mgr. Tim Schuenke – one about the City’s attempted acquisition of the 720 Garden property [pdf], the other about the City’s police department investigation [pdf] which discussed a possible “separation agreement” (a/ka/, a “buy-out”) for Chief Caudill.

We applaud Schmidt for recognizing that the Illinois Open Meetings Act (“IOMA”) exists to ensure that as much public business as possible is done in full view of the press and the public; and that while IOMA permits certain limited matters to be dealt with in closed session, it does not require it.  So the bottom line is that any time our aldermen vote to go into closed session, they are doing so not because they have to, but because they want to.  

1 comment so far

How bad is it that we have to rely on one – and only one – alderman IN THIS ENTIRE CITY to get the truth about what’s going on behind the scenes?????



Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

(required)

(optional and not displayed)